High Achiever to People Leader: Simple, Right?

You’ve always been the high achiever.

Top of your class. Star performer at work.

Now, you’ve earned a promotion to lead a team of high-performers in a fast-growing, high-visibility division. It should feel like the natural next step and at first, it does.

You come in energized, armed with goals, strategies, and a strong belief in your emotional intelligence. You’re ready to deliver results and drive impact.But then… things get complicated.

Your team resists.They’re not responding to your plan.

You sense they’re holding back or worse, shutting you out.

You reach out to trusted mentors, and their responses rattle you:“You’ve inherited the best.

It turns out that managing high-achievers, especially when you are one, isn’t just a leadership challenge.

It’s an identity shift.

And here’s where the Immunity to Change framework comes in.

You’ve been operating from a mindset that’s brought you success:Set the bar high. Push through. Do it yourself if needed. Deliver.

But leading others, especially independent, intelligent, motivated people, requires a new kind of strength: collaboration, adaptability, and trust in others.

And that shift isn’t just behavioral, it’s internal.

Let’s break it down using Harvard research on hidden commitments.

What’s Holding You Back Isn’t What You Think

When your team pushes back or disconnects, your instinct might be to work harder, push more, or prove yourself. But what if that reaction is actually part of the problem?

You might consciously be committed to being a collaborative leader…

…but unconsciously committed to:

• Always being the best performer

• Never appearing uncertain

• Being the one who “gets it done” no matter what

  
  

These hidden commitments aren’t flaws. They’re old survival strategies. They helped you succeed as an individual contributor, but they’re now blocking your growth as a leader.

This is exactly the kind of internal contradiction the Immunity to Change framework reveals and transforms.

Let’s Talk About Motivation

Harvard psychologist David McClelland identified three core human drivers that shape how we lead and relate:

• Achievement – the drive to excel

• Power – the drive to influence or control

• Affiliation – the drive to connect and belong

  
  

Your achievement mindset got you here but unmanaged, it can cause tunnel vision.If you’re only measuring success by hitting goals, you may unintentionally overlook the human dynamics that make team performance possible.

Unchecked, your strengths can become stressors.

You may find yourself:

• Prioritizing results over relationships

• Overworking to maintain your edge

• Struggling to let others contribute in ways you can’t control

  
  

And the cost?A team that tunes out.A leader who feels alone.A role that once felt like a promotion… now feeling like a burden.

The Way Through

At Mary Printz Coaching, I work with high-achieving leaders using the Immunity to Change methodology to uncover the hidden patterns that sabotage growth—and replace them with conscious, aligned action.

We don’t just look at what you’re doing.We look at what you’re protecting—and what you're ready to let go of.

Because your next level of leadership isn’t about achieving more.

It’s about becoming someone who can lead from a place of clarity, grounded confidence, and deep connection.

It starts by asking:

• What do I assume will happen if I stop being the highest achiever in the room?

• What am I afraid I’ll lose if I lean into shared ownership?

• What identity am I holding onto that no longer serves this new chapter?

• 
  

Leadership isn’t about proving yourself.

It’s about knowing yourself and leading from that place.

Ready to lead from the inside out? Let’s talk.

About Mary Printz, M.Ed.

Engage. Equip. Elevate.

Mary Printz, M.Ed., is an Executive Coach, speaker, and founder of Mary Printz Coaching and Accelerated Potential Academy. With decades of experience in educational leadership and executive coaching, Mary specializes in helping high achievers and teams move beyond hidden barriers and into their next level of personal and professional growth.

Her work blends the science of adult development with emotional intelligence, trauma-informed practices, and the Immunity to Change™ framework. Whether she’s coaching leaders, consulting, or speaking, Mary’s approach is deeply transformational, equipping clients to release outdated survival strategies and lead from a place of clarity, courage, and grounded strength.

Clients often describe Mary as someone who sees potential others miss and knows how to unlock it. Her mission is simple:

Engage the whole person. Equip them with insight. Elevate their impact.

Ready to accelerate your growth?

Email: mary@maryprintz.com

Call: 403-866-3806

Learn more: www.maryprintz.com